Board logo

標題: 轉載:1994年 ATV 六君子事件 [打印本頁]
作者: soli    時間: 2011-6-3 15:11     標題: 轉載:1994年 ATV 六君子事件

http://sites.google.com/site/sixfourevent/atvnews

1994年，香港亞洲電視台購買了西班牙攝製隊在現場拍攝的六四清場片段，並製做了一個六四特輯。亞視管理層一度禁止新聞部播放這個清場片段。其後雖然這段錄像以一個特輯形式播出，卻惹起爭議，引發六位資深新聞工作者集體請辭，人稱亞視六君子事件。

當許多人追問著清場時究竟發生甚麼事時？其實除了中國一早已播放出清場片段外，西班牙的攝影隊在當時也在天安門廣場，他們拍攝了整個清場過程。

現在請你們用自己的眼睛，去看看六四時天安間廣場究竟發生了甚麼事情。聽不懂廣東話的朋友，可以 按此 廣東話文字翻譯：同時做參考。現場畫面自0.42開始。

亞視時事追擊 ─ 歷史的空白：解放軍清場片段3

1994年，香港亞洲電視台購買了西班牙攝製隊在現場拍攝的六四清場片段，並製做了一個六四特輯。亞視管理層一度禁止新聞部播放這個清場片段。其後雖然這段錄像以一個特輯形式播出，卻惹起爭議，引發六位資深新聞工作者集體請辭，人稱亞視六君子事件。

當許多人追問著清場時究竟發生甚麼事時？其實除了中國一早已播放出清場片段外，西班牙的攝影隊在當時也在天安門廣場，他們拍攝了整個清場過程。

現在請你們用自己的眼睛，去看看六四時天安間廣場究竟發生了甚麼事情。聽不懂廣東話的朋友，可以 按此 廣東話文字翻譯：同時做參考。現場畫面自0.42開始。

亞視時事追擊 ─ 歷史的空白：解放軍清場片段3

[youtube]6ra2M7sKLaU[/youtube]


似乎西班牙攝製隊最慷慨，肯將足本的清場錄像公開出來。雖然影像公開時已是1994年，但是這也算一份遲來的禮物，將當時影像上的歷史空白補足。

有香港的朋友指出在六四當時的香港電視新聞，都有一瞬間的錄影顯示，拍到在天安門廣場內的現場情況。暫時的資料中，有網友陸續發現64當天, 駐守在天安門廣場內的記者有1)加拿大CBC，2)紐約WTN, 3) 西班牙攝制隊, 4) 亞視新聞部, 5) 美國CBS電視台。可是在八九年與六四有關的新聞中，清場時的完整影片欠缺，畫面的解說都是解放軍以槍及坦克對手無寸鐵的學生進行屠殺。

以下是一篇非常詳細的分析文章，值得一看。一直以來，我們都相信著新聞主播的報導，這篇文章試圖以六四當時的新聞畫面及視頻將當時的真相重組。

為何89年「香港電視新聞」不報導真相, 隱瞞真相?
明明天安門廣場學生是和平撤退，大家都離開了，為甚麼六四那天《明報》全版黑色描述解放軍在天安門對手無寸鐵的學生進行屠殺？香港的所有傳媒一致讉責中國政府殺人，甚至是左報《文匯》《大公》對六四解放軍血染天安門及屠城的報導程度比起《明報》不遑多讓？
六四時的香港報章新聞


學生們自己同意撤退，那麼照理就不存在鎮壓之說。紛紛攘攘了幾個月的學運，以這樣的情形落幕，當事人自己應該也很唏噓。

題外話：有人留意到，視頻7:51開始有個人開著三輪車很輕鬆地從坦克車中間穿了過去，似乎那個人不怎麼害怕坦克嘛！


天安門廣場清場的圖片


時事追擊─歷史的空白片段一

[youtube]UdNg469JRl4[/youtube]

時事追擊─歷史的空白片段二

[youtube]lxNbozuWVFU[/youtube]
作者: blue20ae    時間: 2011-6-3 18:46     標題: Eyewitness To Tiananmen Spring

Jan Wong
Globe and Mail Beijing correspondent.

… I was really afraid the students would get massacred, but they weren't. They gathered them, and … then they forced them to go out through a gauntlet, literally a gauntlet, where they hit them as they left. Then the students filed out through the south end past Chairman Mao's mausoleum; they turned right at Kentucky Fried Chicken; then they went back north to the Boulevard of Eternal Peace [Chang'an Boulevard]. Then just at that intersection, when they arrived at the Boulevard of Eternal Peace, some students swore at the tanks who were waiting, and the tanks turned on their motors and crushed about 10 or 11 students. This is about 6:00 a.m., so it's daylight because it's June, so everyone can see this. …

That day, of course, when the sun came up, everybody was really angry. Remember, the whole city heard it. Ten million people heard the army coming in, and they heard the sirens, and they heard all the screaming and shooting. So they gathered at the corner, and about 50 or 60 or 80 people cursed the soldiers who were now guarding the square. … You could see the commander give an order, because suddenly all the rifles would come up. There would be one row of soldiers kneeling, one row standing. It was like a shooting range. Then all the people realized that the guns were pointed at them, and they'd go running past the hotel. I felt like I was watching some terrible opera: The people [would] go running past the hotel, and then the soldiers would fire in their backs. They would fall right in front of the hotel. Maybe five or six people would be shot. And then, unlike the night before, when you could rescue them, if you tried to approach them, they would shoot. They would shoot anyone who tried to help those people, so they would just be lying in the square. … The soldiers shot everybody -- doctors, nurses, anybody, rescuers. Just everybody was being shot at. …

But the odd thing was that after a little while, like 40 minutes, an hour, people would gather their nerve again and crawl back to the corner and start screaming at the soldiers. … The commander would eventually give another signal, and the soldiers would raise their rifles again, and the people go, "Oh, my God!," and they would run away, and they'd shoot more in the backs. This went on more than half a dozen times in the day. It was to me unbelievable that I'm just watching it and counting the bodies. … I just can't believe it.

The only reason they left is it started to rain around late afternoon, a nice, gentle drizzle, and everybody went home. I thought, such a strange country -- they're not afraid of dying, but they don't want to get wet. So that was the end of that. …

Read more: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/fr ... .html#ixzz1OGtb9PTH
作者: soli    時間: 2011-6-3 19:33

西方記者喔~ 有拍片嗎?

美國之音說天安們廣場死了上萬人呢。
作者: sheep    時間: 2011-6-3 20:58

西方記者喔~ 有拍片嗎?

美國之音說天安們廣場死了上萬人呢。
soli 發表於 2011-6-3 19:33



    你又有冇錄低
POST 條 LINK 上來聽吓
作者: blue20ae    時間: 2011-6-4 07:55

西方記者喔~ 有拍片嗎?

soli 發表於 2011-6-3 19:33



Here you go... http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=Tiananmen+Square+Massacre+&aq=f

Over 1,000 clips just on Youtube.
作者: blue20ae    時間: 2011-6-4 07:58

美國之音說天安們廣場死了上萬人呢。
soli 發表於 2011-6-3 19:33



    Do your home work la.  Actually it was the Red Soviet comrade came up with the highest death estimation, not the American.
作者: soli    時間: 2011-6-4 18:33

回復 5# blue20ae

我是說你上面貼的情況﹐軍隊一排排向人開搶﹐坦克一次crush呢D大話呀。
有片嗎?



歡迎光臨 溫哥華老友記討論區 (http://loyaukee.com/forum/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2