溫哥華老友記討論區 - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: 本人对学校部份教材的评价 [打印本頁]

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-18 20:01 標題: 本人对学校部份教材的评价

本帖最後由 szasz 於 2012-4-18 20:08 編輯

[youtube]3zSA9Rm2PZA[/youtube]

该段影片为本地某所大学某科目中之教材
本人认为影片含有不良意识
而教师并未曾替学生就该段影片作出合理或相应的诠译

无奈影片属一女权主义者於1975年的作品
而今天的Martha Rosler 更是在学界内举足轻重
故~无言~

但老实说这样的东西对於心志未成熟的莘莘学子
本人认为绝对是意识不良兼教坏细路
*If taught without appropriate guildlines*

所以顺便给大家看看
边间学校边位老师就
无可奉告~

作者: 布小熊 時間: 2012-4-18 20:25

mmm... I actually enjoyed watching it. Considering it represented something to be said in the 70's.
btw... I think if your kid is old enough to enter into 大学! S/he isn't so dumb.
They need to look at everything with an open mind.

作者: Look4chrisng 時間: 2012-4-18 21:49

本帖最後由 Look4chrisng 於 2012-4-18 21:51 編輯

Where is the problem here? What brothers you in the video?

Women's Studies are the best classes you can take in a University, except Burnham Young.

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2012-4-18 22:32

心志未成熟 and in university?

sounds like the typical shxt post 90 generation

superb video anyway
really enjoyed it

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2012-4-18 22:33

oh
and if the kid is still 心志未成熟 at university age
the parents are the guilty party
not the teachers

作者: fibbi 時間: 2012-4-19 00:00

In high school may be not as good...in University...come on...
there are many things way worse than this I think...just watch movies...

作者: imvitasoy 時間: 2012-4-19 07:05

在下唔睇唔明佢做咩春

作者: 布小熊 時間: 2012-4-19 12:09

回復 7# imvitasoy
Not sure if this may help you:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiotics_of_the_Kitchen

But you can also view it in your own way.
I like some of her gentle and then vigorous handling of the utensils.

Reminds me some of Pina Bausch's dance pieces. (few modern dance choreographer that I can named)

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2012-4-19 12:28

My view is rather simple. To me it's just a nice demonstration of how various kitchen pieces can be used in ways that nobody would think of. It's just outward thinking.

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-19 17:14

he he thanks for all your support

as in right now i am on academic probation

mainly due to that course full of marxism

[& me rejecting their materials]

i suppose it took me months of reading to get to the point in which i actually interpreted the stabbing motions in that video into sth bad. as in homicidal/manslaughter kind of suggestion [with all the Marxism in my brain at the moment I was watching it]

i prefer to live in reality in which no one is entitled to harm any individual nor induce any bodily ... harm. and when a person [in a video broadcasted in a lecture hall] was swinging a knife in stabbing gestures with an unidentifiable facial expression as opposed to many of our chinese martial artists professionally handling all kinds of weapons with faces & bodies full of grace ...

but that i kind of expressed already in my school's moodle site but not quite to the face of my prof & my TA. they might have more right than i am in that manner with regard to their 'teaching' position plus i paid them to teach me in a way so. for me in reality i do not need another movie or video game to give me a portal to unfold my potentials nor possibilities as in where [else] should i be in this world [exclusively for living out my fantasy i rely on myself & me only to think of what is otherwise impossible to be done] [and I am saying that only for those who choose to live in virtual reality & separate yourself into an out-of-the-mind person] [a person not welcomed in real so to speak]

maybe this is where i draw the line. i've been, and was able to, living in that fantasy world for a long long time to [be able to] see if there is a tiny bit of [error] as in making a suggestion to another human of wrong [from right] that being said only under circumstances when an individual's life is threatened or with substantial concern of his/her safety or under the threat to be raped as in women's case [or men included] should one draw a weapon for self-protection purpose imo

[again these thoughts were all in response to my class material to balance out my brain] that together with my other classmates who saw that artist swinging the knife as a joke. mainly because they are 心志未成熟 and so am I 尤其係我, 應該咁講 when I opened up to learn. but hey thanks ya'll for all your responses. it helps.

as in the field of art, there are many others conceptual/performance artist eg chris burden who does things with physical bodies [not that i will recommend for any of you] & there is an artist from mainland china who allegedly used human fetus in his art [and FBI was after his s in 2001] the art world has a wide opened ... unlimited ... really broad ... space if you need it. but as an artist / student [so called if necessary][self proclaimed] with some art education [mostly forgotten] i would recommend nothing for nobody to try as new. not sure if my words mean anything at all but i see you guys as the 局外人 [compared to me as the 當事人] and i am not going to appeal for my grades due to ... my brain situation ... rather get some icecream etc by all means i do [try to] respect all schools of thoughts as in the same as our hundred schools of thoughts 諸子百家 too bad my brain seems a bit congested if not in chaos. already. TTYL

and not sure if by me splitting my brain apart into all these fragments is any healthy but that seems necessary. i just needed to know but obviously i don't. crossing my finger everything turns out alright at the end for everyone esp me

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-19 17:29

in short, i think it is a killing in disguise for the audience's appeal. maybe it was right in 1975 with the feminist movement. no matter how poetic or artistic it was. i am seeing this because i am under the influence of their Marxists' thinking. better stop now or i will 洗版 if i carry on.

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2012-4-19 17:55

in short, i think it is a killing in disguise for the audience's appeal. maybe it was right in 1975 ...
szasz 發表於 2012/4/19 17:29

I had the same impression 3 seconds into the film. I think it's a mind opening reminder to all of us that kitchen utensils can be used in violent or unconventional ways. My initial thought was that this was a response to domestic violence or rapes on women. Maybe that wasn't the original intent but it's a good clip.

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2012-4-19 17:56

and please share more art stuff here. Too much tvb crap here.

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-19 20:00

回復 8# 布小熊

嗳，這裡不是有人说过小时候跟妹妹一块儿扮大侠拿番茄酱當血桨的嗎。还有把男生从洗手间打发赶走。搅笑好棒。

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-19 20:03

回復 13# 快樂牛郎

我刚才重看那段片，那些马克思的東西好像已经不存在。起碼現在是這樣。之前还连续吃了几个松饼。

作者: imvitasoy 時間: 2012-4-20 08:21

睇完網上介紹，先知道E條片名氣咁很大。哇靠~! 70年代非專業攝錄技術，竟然都有得唱好理論一番。果然真系 "我讀書少你呃得就呃"...... 洋人做神方程式，meaning, 都是後加上去的，再加幾個學者唱幾唱，又可以起鬨，基本上同TBB 盛女分別不大。有時覺得旺角MK 仔說話反而有紋有路。

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-21 21:43

在下孤漏寡聞所以係度查緊咩係躂皮和MK仔是指什麼人 i assume the term refers to young ppl hanging out at Mong Kok with a certain set of distinctive characters

作者: imvitasoy 時間: 2012-4-21 22:04

哈哈在下只是貪玩，成日喜歡講呢類香港土話，唔好見笑。最好你順便，幫在下查下“撬牆腳" 英文係咩，在下搵左十幾年，請教左十幾個英美澳加純鬼，仍然木宰羊.....

作者: szasz 時間: 2012-4-21 22:43

哈哈在下只是貪玩，成日喜歡講呢類香港土話，唔好見笑。最好你順便，幫在下查下“撬牆腳" 英文係咩，在下 ...
imvitasoy 發表於 2012-4-21 22:04

呢件任務你做左十幾年
好有價值

作者: imvitasoy 時間: 2012-4-22 07:57

呢件任務你做左十幾年
好有價值
szasz 發表於 2012-4-21 22:43

人生如夢，老人家驚覺活在當下，還有甚麼比好玩更有價值的呢？

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2012-4-22 18:26

please keep the conversation going

作者: 布小熊 時間: 2012-4-22 20:56

回復布小熊

嗳，這裡不是有人说过小时候跟妹妹一块儿扮大侠拿番茄酱當血桨的嗎。还有把男生从洗手间打 ...
szasz 發表於 2012-4-19 08:00 PM

? what does that have to do with this topic? I was like 8... and we didn't use ketchup.

歡迎光臨溫哥華老友記討論區 (http://loyaukee.com/forum/)