溫哥華老友記討論區 - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: 對泳兒有甚麼看法﹖ [打印本頁]

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2008-9-25 12:35 標題: 對泳兒有甚麼看法﹖

個人非常不明白因何泳兒會這麼紅。。。

她樣子唔靚﹐矮﹐身材唔知真定假﹐就算係真都唔算好好。。。唱歌好唔好聽唔知﹐但而家的錄音技術﹐只要不是啞的就可以做歌星﹐想問大家﹐有人鐘意泳兒的嗎﹖她到底哪兒好﹖為何雜誌都是她的照片﹐好似好紅那般。。。

有無人可以指教一下﹖

作者: Catpiano 時間: 2008-9-25 12:52

Her voice is good .. good songs .. good singing .. I can hardly think of other singers .. have that BASIC requirement as singers ...

I dont know if she is 紅 or not .. as I dont listen to HK songs that much anymore, usually are from friends or my brother .. when I heard 泳兒's songs .. I asked " wow .. good wor .. who is she? "

So .. since then, I beg my wife to BT her songs for me ..

Who else can sing? I think "Way Lan" is good .. um .. who else??

Actually, I think 泳兒 is ok looking wor .. at least, prettier then 97.4% girls I know here ...

作者: chunsh 時間: 2008-9-25 13:07

原帖由 Catpiano 於 2008-9-25 13:52 發表
Her voice is good .. good songs .. good singing .. I can hardly think of other singers .. have that BASIC requirement as singers ...

I dont know if she is 紅 or not .. as I dont listen to HK son ...

Kay
Tse On Kay

作者: siumaibb 時間: 2008-9-25 13:29

原帖由 Littleprince 於 2008-9-25 13:35 發表
個人非常不明白因何泳兒會這麼紅。。。

她樣子唔靚﹐矮﹐身材唔知真定假﹐就算係真都唔算好好。。。唱歌好唔好聽唔知﹐但而家的錄音技術﹐只要不是啞的就可以做歌星﹐想問大家﹐有人鐘意泳兒的嗎﹖她到底哪兒好﹖為何雜誌都是她的照片 ...

我反而唔明點解你咁憎佢？你老公好鐘意佢？

我唔係佢Fans，亦都唔係話太鐘意佢D歌，亦都唔覺佢係特別紅。不過，佢把聲真係唔錯。。話時話，你有無聽過佢唱歌？如果有，你真係覺得可以用效果執出黎？如果無，你單憑佢個樣黎judge佢，會唔會太天真太傻？

作者: Hyde 時間: 2008-9-25 13:37

her songs are good
[youtube]em3oTPw0aWE[/youtube]

[youtube]4jLb_zKCmsA[/youtube]

[youtube]oC4kPC3EN6c[/youtube]

[ 本帖最後由 Hyde 於 2008-9-25 14:41 編輯 ]

作者: fibbi 時間: 2008-9-25 13:50

Wing Yee's song is not bad wor...her voice also good...
I think she's even better than "wai Larn" (in terms of voice)...
So I don't hate her in particular...

Not like when I see "stephy" singing...I will switch channel right away...

作者: GAClone 時間: 2008-9-25 14:36

i think 泳兒's selling point is that she can ACTUALLY sing! so saying "唱歌好唔好聽唔知﹐但而家的錄音技術﹐只要不是啞的就可以做歌星..." seems odd...she's a SINGER and for someone to not know her music/singing before judging whether she should be 紅 or not .. seems...well...premature. and i think you judge whether a singer can sing when he/she sings LIVE. so dont just listen to studio recordings, look up their live performances on youtube~

as for 泳兒's songs...well some of them r good, but i think they can be better. and i liked her better in her 1st and 2nd album, now her company's trying to make her 'sexier' which isnt really her style i think...kinda throws me off a bit to be honest

hope that helps!

作者: its_visa 時間: 2008-9-25 14:43

Wai larn's singing is soooooooo bad...
holy crap...@__@"
her singing = no more breath gum....
and...her look.....................hmmmm.............leave for u to decide la...

but....Wing Yee is a good singer, know how 2 sing and project her voice`` Very good```

作者: mibu 時間: 2008-9-25 14:45

hey buddy
you still havent gotten use to it?
there are tons of people like that
to name a few...stephy, kathy, teresa, etc etc etc

作者: CWong 時間: 2008-9-25 14:50

Can't swim!!

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2008-9-25 14:53

原帖由 siumaibb 於 2008-9-25 14:29 發表

我反而唔明點解你咁憎佢？你老公好鐘意佢？

我唔係佢Fans，亦都唔係話太鐘意佢D歌，亦都唔覺佢係特別紅。不過，佢把聲真係唔錯。。話時話，你有無聽過佢唱歌？如果有，你真係覺得可以用效果執出黎？如果無，你單憑佢個樣黎judge佢，會唔 ...

hahaha... my husband also hates her... he has the same feeling as me... curious why she is so popular?

作者: shutterbug 時間: 2008-9-25 15:27

Wing Yee's singing is OK, voice is pretty good, her live performance is slightly better than Janice (Wai Lan). I don't know what's wrong with Janice, her live sucks soooo bad sometimes, worse than her boss Leon! However, on CD and singing English songs I think Janice is the best in HK.

The problem is that her looks isn't that appealing, otherwise she could be better in the biz.

Her first CD was good, seond OK, dont' even know if she has a third one...so...LOL you know how much I like her...

OTOH, I'm still listening to 孫燕姿, Janice and Kay all the time. BTW, 孫燕姿 is at the top of my list

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2008-9-25 15:29

wondering why everyone is comparing her to wai lan?

作者: shutterbug 時間: 2008-9-25 15:34

why not? hk singers and around the same time

but she's from Singapore I think...

作者: akshea 時間: 2008-9-25 15:37

"但而家的錄音技術﹐只要不是啞的就可以做歌星" That might be true.. but ... if the 錄音技術 can make anyone sings like 泳兒, how come there are still singers out there that sings like crap.

Another girl that 泳兒 can compare to .. might be "Wong Yuen Zi" .. but Wong Yuen Zi is still way better than her... Her voice is so crispy and sweet.

作者: Hyde 時間: 2008-9-25 16:18

王婉之 is even uglier then vincy...

actually, she even makes vincy looks pretty LOL

作者: its_visa 時間: 2008-9-25 16:25

原帖由 Hyde 於 2008-9-25 17:18 發表
王婉之 is even uglier then vincy...

actually, she even makes vincy looks pretty LOL

so agree with u!
王婉之 = freaking bird face! gosh....
and hell...i hate her voice..especially when she TALKS...annoys the crap outta me!

作者: Catpiano 時間: 2008-9-25 16:55

I think both Way Lan and Wing Yee sing well .. 王婉之 is ok .. but a bit alternative songs ... and on 王婉之 case .. then for sure, kind of bad looking ....

I think Tse On Kay .. or Cheng Yoon .. are not bad? but dont know how they look like ... lol

作者: yungfourfour 時間: 2008-9-25 18:02

Ivana's look is kinda bitchy but I don't see it from wing yee's face.... which makes her more "smooth for eyes"

And when you see wing yee's interviews on TV.... unlike the typical "EEG" stars, her talks actually doesn't have any "er er er " and her mandarin+english are very fluent.... very presentable

and of course I love her voice

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2008-9-25 19:03

廖化作先鋒。。。

作者: maldini 時間: 2008-9-25 21:43

原帖由 Littleprince 於 2008-9-25 13:35 發表
個人非常不明白因何泳兒會這麼紅。。。

她樣子唔靚﹐矮﹐身材唔知真定假﹐就算係真都唔算好好。。。唱歌好唔好聽唔知﹐但而家的錄音技術﹐只要不是啞的就可以做歌星﹐想問大家﹐有人鐘意泳兒的嗎﹖她到底哪兒好﹖為何雜誌都是她的照片 ...

泳兒 is a very nice singer.

作者: Purpleheart 時間: 2008-9-25 23:10

個人非常不明白因何 XX 會這麼紅。。。

她樣子唔靚﹐矮﹐身材唔知真定假﹐就算係真都唔算好好。。。唱歌好唔好聽唔知﹐但而家的錄音技術﹐只要不是啞的就可以做歌星﹐想問大家﹐有人鐘意 XX 的嗎﹖她到底哪兒好﹖為何雜誌都是她的照片 ...

XX = stephy
XX = twins
XX = Teresa
XX =

點解會有人批評泳兒的唱功架? 起碼好過以上的人
仲有, 得閒上youtube 聽聽泳兒唱 life 啦~~ 人地唱歌夠氣冇走音~ 又有台風

鷹王的人我個個都唔鐘意, 除左泳兒之外~ 因為我知佢係靠實力, 而唔係靠陪老細上床, 露點, 走光而紅的

作者: Hyde 時間: 2008-9-25 23:18

stephy is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo cute
teresa is pretty

作者: mcjohnjohn 時間: 2008-9-25 23:36

原帖由 Purpleheart 於 2008-9-26 15:10 發表
鷹王的人我個個都唔鐘意, 除左泳兒之外~ 因為我知佢係靠實力, 而唔係靠陪老細上床, 露點, 走光而紅的

你好似知道鷹王既內幕... 可唔可以透露多少少?

作者: Caffie 時間: 2008-9-26 02:01

聽過泳兒唱live, 把聲仲靚!
呢D 真係叫做唱得

作者: mui122 時間: 2008-9-26 15:22

原帖由 Catpiano 於 2008-9-25 13:52 發表
Her voice is good .. good songs .. good singing .. I can hardly think of other singers .. have that BASIC requirement as singers ...

I dont know if she is 紅 or not .. as I dont listen to HK son ...

Ure serious??
is it THAT bad in Alberta???
I think WingYi is sooooooo uglyyyyyy... she looks like a horse face
anyone watched her "dai fai woot" commercials??
They're pretty scary... especially the early ones (when Tao man chak was still their spokesperson)

but her voice is truly beautiful
which proves that God is fair
ugly face but beautiful voice

I think the person with the best balance of appearance and singing technique is Kay Tse
she's got a beautiful voice as well
she's not gorgeous but I think she's quite pretty

everyone else either have bad technique +good face (ie. hmmm seriously I can't think of a recent star I believe is truly pretty...) or good technique + bad face (Joey Yung)

作者: Catpiano 時間: 2008-9-26 22:01

Trust me ... if you put WING YEE in Calgary ... she is HOT !!! LOL

(be fair, should say put her into the ASIAN SINGLE GROUP here, then she is hot ..

)

[ 本帖最後由 Catpiano 於 2008-9-26 23:10 編輯 ]

作者: spoonek4 時間: 2008-9-27 02:21

點解好似大部份人都係講個樣靚唔靚﹖講真自問唔係靚仔，對人地都唔要求咁多，唔會嚇親人就ok，反正都係聽佢d 歌，唱得差+歌唔好，樣再靚都o徒氣！

我覺得泳兒d 歌好多(又或者太多)高音，同埋可能係寫曲同詞既問題，d 歌唔係太襟聽，相反王菀之就ok，d 歌變化比較大d ，早幾年佢黎溫哥華做歌創表演果陣見過佢，真人亦都平易近人冇咩擺款，起碼唔會架住個墨鏡慌死人認到咁。

我覺得hk 需要多d ivana 呢一類識寫作曲詞同玩下樂器(如彈琴/ 結他)而唔係只係出書同寫真集既歌手.....

作者: chihiro 時間: 2008-9-28 09:01

I like Ivana too~ She has such a nice voice! I saw her once in Pacific Centre in downtown, she was so friendly!
Wing Yi & Kay Tse are good too, way better than those who do not know how to sing in HK.

作者: peter236 時間: 2008-9-29 13:27

原帖由 mcjohnjohn 於 2008-9-26 00:36 發表

你好似知道鷹王既內幕... 可唔可以透露多少少?

Comeon, how does he know for sure?

作者: Hyde 時間: 2008-9-29 17:11

anything with EEG is public knowledge

作者: peter236 時間: 2008-9-30 15:33

原帖由 shutterbug 於 2008-9-25 16:34 發表
why not? hk singers and around the same time

but she's from Singapore I think...

Comeon, she immigrated from HK to Singapore. So she is from HK.

作者: mui122 時間: 2008-9-30 19:33

原帖由 peter236 於 2008-9-30 16:33 發表

Comeon, she immigrated from HK to Singapore. So she is from HK.

whats your point here?

作者: peter236 時間: 2008-9-30 20:35

原帖由 mui122 於 2008-9-30 20:33 發表

whats your point here?

Someone said she is from Singapore. But she actually immigrated to Singapore from HK. So she is a Hong Konger, simple as that.

作者: Catpiano 時間: 2008-9-30 21:52

COMEON .. it is LYK .. we dont need ANY point here .. lol

Yeah ! COMEON!

作者: mui122 時間: 2008-10-1 01:01

原帖由 peter236 於 2008-9-30 21:35 發表

Someone said she is from Singapore. But she actually immigrated to Singapore from HK. So she is a Hong Konger, simple as that.

so what if she is a honger?
the person that said she came from singapore was just pointing out that fact to state similarities between wingyi and janice...
so r u trying to say that wingyi and janice are not alike and should not be compared or....what? cuz if u were just trying to say she came from hong kong...we all knew that...so thus..ur argument was pointless

作者: peter236 時間: 2008-10-1 01:46

原帖由 mui122 於 2008-10-1 02:01 發表

so what if she is a honger?
the person that said she came from singapore was just pointing out that fact to state similarities between wingyi and janice...
so r u trying to say that wingyi and jan ...

Comeon, you are just thinking too much. I was just telling the other person that wing yi is from Hong Kong. I don't care if she is from HK or Singapore. I am not going to compare her with anyone else, hahaha.

作者: mui122 時間: 2008-10-1 02:27

HAHA alrite..
we ALL knew she originally came from hong kong
so i guess ur point WAS a bit pointless

作者: peter236 時間: 2008-10-1 02:29

原帖由 mui122 於 2008-10-1 03:27 發表
HAHA alrite..
we ALL knew she originally came from hong kong
so i guess ur point WAS a bit pointless

Hahaha, but that person didn't know she is from Hong Kong.

作者: mui122 時間: 2008-10-1 02:44

原帖由 shutterbug 於 2008-9-25 16:34 發表
why not? hk singers and around the same time

but she's from Singapore I think...

she said she thinks Wingyi is from Singapore
but she didnt say she wasnt originally from Hong Kong
Wingyi was in fact brought up in Singapore
so she was right
I was born in Hong Kong brought up in Vancouver and now I work in Hong Kong
I would tell ppl I'm from Vancouver
that doesnt mean I'm not a Hong Kong citizen

anyway~ its not important~ just bored and yaking

作者: shutterbug 時間: 2008-10-1 07:24

hm....since when shutterbug is a "she"....

Singapore or not....doesn't really matter la....

[ 本帖最後由 shutterbug 於 2008-10-1 08:37 編輯 ]

作者: mui122 時間: 2008-10-1 09:43

原帖由 shutterbug 於 2008-10-1 08:24 發表
hm....since when shutterbug is a "she"....

Singapore or not....doesn't really matter la....

oh oops =P
randomly selected a pronoun
ure lucky i didnt pick it
hahahahhaha

歡迎光臨溫哥華老友記討論區 (http://loyaukee.com/forum/)