原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-1 13:41 發表
A trash film by any standard.
Shameless profiteering on the current economic crisis.

奧斯卡以為選佢就叫做跟隨民意
其實顯露出班評審都只不過係普通人

原帖由 ytyger 於 2009/3/1 13:41 發表


just wondering, have u even seen the movie, which part of it do u think is trash?

原帖由 sheep 於 2009/3/3 22:53 發表
導演都应該記一功掛

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-4 12:57 發表
People think a movie is enjoyable when it's specifically tailored to make you feel enjoyable.

原帖由 ecwkwok 於 2009/3/4 13:15 發表
要娛樂，有娛樂。要歌舞，有歌舞。要愛情，有愛情。要message，有message。 仲想點？

原帖由 fibbi 於 2009/3/4 12:43 發表


Is that what movie is for? Tailor to make people feel enjoyable?
If the movie make people 產生共鳴, it's good isn't it?

原帖由 daimo 於 2009/3/4 15:06 發表
Do you have examples of good films?

I do agree with your comment about Yip Man.

(I haven't seen slumdog, so no comments about it)

a good film shows a new perspective about the world;

a good film reveals a level of reality that is often forgotten by human;

a good film inspires me to another artistic level;

a good film brings out beauty and magic that nobody has ever envisioned.

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-4 15:46 發表
It depends on the viewer.

For me,
a good film shows a new perspective about the world;
a good film reveals a level of reality that is often forgotten by human;
a good film inspires me to another ar ...

原帖由 fibbi 於 2009/3/5 16:31 發表

很高興見到對電影很有要求的觀眾，but sometimes, we do need some pure entertainment. Whether it's "comic" (無厘頭) that gives us some laugh, or action that gives us some excitement, or others.
To me, th ...

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-5 18:00 發表


That's why I am not saying there's anything wrong with the movie or you shouldn't watch it.  But my point is that, it's not a good movie based on merits.  It's a commercially successful movie though ...

原帖由 fibbi 於 2009/3/5 17:10 發表


Got it!

Btw, have you watched "Gloomy Sunday"
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0155722/

What do you think about this?

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-4 14:46 發表


It depends on the viewer.

For me,
a good film shows a new perspective about the world;
a good film reveals a level of reality that is often forgotten by human;
a good film inspires me to another ar ...

原帖由 chobit 於 2009/3/5 21:27 發表
In my opinion, it's just that this movie isn't your cup of tea, but yet it's still a good movie, instead of calling it trash..!  It's matter of taste.  Just like you don't say Durians are trash only b ...