返回列表 發帖
It's exactly the same reason why people saying buying a lightly used 2nd hand car is a much smarter buy than paying for a brand spanking new vehicle. It's also the same reason why every veteran (motorcycle) rider will recommend a newbie rider to start off on a second hand beat up newbie bike before they move on to something bigger and better.
Lik 發表於 2010-1-31 01:05

This is what I don't agree, somehow.
Unless you know well enough about cars, I won't suggest a "newbie" to buy used cars cuz in case the car break down in the middle of the road or something happens, they will have no idea what's going on and what to do. But in fact, I will suggest them to get a new car from any dealer, in case anything happens, they are "hand-tail-free" and simply take the car to the dealer and get it fixed.

TOP

See post #4:

And then see post #17 where Chobit made a good point of caution about used camera gear:

It's true that some used gear have been heavily used (or even abused), which is why the buyer ha ...

1) most people are not experts on cars
2) on any given day, there are far more people buying used cars than there are buying new
3) most cars run well enough that they don't require frequent repairs

You know, I really hate to bust you like this all the time.
Lik 發表於 2010-1-31 11:43


Thanks for pointing these out again.
However, choosing an used or brand new DSLR is the second issue, first thing is, why a newbie shouldn't get a DSLR to learn in the first place? Who said once get into an interest, one should keep it for a life time? You want to tell me you guys who have DSLR are now regret and want to sell them all out, and want to go back to use prosumer for your rest of your life? Can you deny that you have short term or longer term enjoyment and fulfillment for the time you had with your DSLR? Why force others to accept your own experience and feeling? One may feel happy enough to play with DSLR for one year or even one month, what's the problem? How many girlfriends did you guys had before? Can you say it's wasting your time cuz you didn't get married with your ex eventually? I just don't see why people discourage newbies to buy a DSLR in the first place, no matter it's used or new.

*****

1) most people are not experts on cars
True. Same as, most people are not professional photographers. You want to tell me only people expert on cars can/should drive nice cars, and only professional photographers can/should use DSLR?

2) on any given day, there are far more people buying used cars than there are buying new
Any statistic to show whether those people who buy used cars are newbies or somewhat experienced or experts?

3) most cars run well enough that they don't require frequent repairs
You mean used or new ones? In fact, same as choosing used cameras and cars (and many other things too), only if you have enough knowledge on that field so you can tell how good or bad the product is, it's always safer to buy used items from a shop/official dealer since they've reasonable QC on the item and give some sort of warranty to buyers. Buying from individual/private sellers is always at higher risk.


[You know, I really hate to bust you like this all the time. ]
You think you're smart? Only because you are so self-centered and always think you are right and ignore other people's need. How smart you are?!

TOP

I am not opposed to new photographers buying dSLR at all. In fact, did you ever see me advocate that at any point in this thread? What I am recommending against, however, is that newbies go out and bu ...
Lik 發表於 2010-1-31 15:11

There are two issues:
1. prosumer vs DSLR;
2. used vs new.

Let's skip no.1 and discuss no.2 without bias.
My concern:
i) Since you people assume "newbie" knows nothing about photography, how can he/she examine the condition of an used camera which is selling by a private/an individual seller (something from the sites you mentioned)? Yes, one might spend less but turn out getting a piece of garbage.
ii) Is it safer to buy used item from a shop that carries certain kind of warranty?

Please answer the questions directly, smart kid.

TOP

Rebel XS with 18-55mm IS Lens $480 http://accessories.dell.com/sna/ ... dhot&redirect=1

Same thing at Vision $478 http://www2.visions.ca/Catalogue/Cate ...
pkphilip 發表於 2010-1-31 22:06

Thanks pkphilip, these are really good deal.
And since the price of this DSLR is pretty comparable to some prosumer such as G11, I think it's definitely no harm to start with a DSLR even for newbies.

TOP

Sigh...

dSLR don't really contain any user serviceable parts at all. Entry level models has more plastic parts, but the mid level dSLR line are built *very* solidly (at least, this is true of bo ...
Lik 發表於 2010-2-1 00:08

Long enough which I didn't go all thru.
But if a "newbie" can do all these, I really don't understand why some people suggest a prosumer over a DSLR.

TOP

LOL~

You asked me for an answer, and I gave it to you. And this is what you tell me.

I rest my case.

-Lik
Lik 發表於 2010-2-1 00:18

Honestly, you didn't answer my questions directly.
So for #2, to buy an older model and/or more well-used camera from a shop which offer a 30 day store credit warranty VS. an individual seller selling you a newer model and/or less-used camera in which you two may likely contact only by emails but no phone number, he/she can grab your money and runaway without even one day warranty and you can never find him/her again. Which case is more risky?

TOP

LOL~

You asked me for an answer, and I gave it to you. And this is what you tell me.

I rest my case.

-Lik
Lik 發表於 2010-2-1 00:18

And if a "newbie" can do all these, he/she is NOT a newbie.

TOP

睇左咁多版,
其實條友係唔多清楚相機既.......
就好似....新牌仔係都要買棍仔跑車......就彈出黎講...新牌仔點解唔可以買棍仔?唔識踩極力子唔係唔俾買棍仔既理由囉!

我真係見過人....係咁揾個"Zoom"制......有人 ...
MoiRhapsody 發表於 2010-2-1 01:44

To compare auto transmission with 棍仔車, you should compare AF with manual camera. You might be an expert in photography, but low common sense.

You guys don't need to agree with me, seems this discussion (argument) should come to an end.

TOP

Doh~

auto tranny = prosumer DC
manual tranny = dSLR

When you can't even see how the analogy compares, why do you even bother to write back?

Can't help it when people just like to make a fool ou ...
Lik 發表於 2010-2-1 12:46

You were the one who invented pin hole camera? Feel free to think you are the king of the world and ignore all other people's perspective and valid facts, only you (you guys) are right. Whenever there are comments and ideas against you (you guys) is like offending your "expertise" (you/you guys think). Very fine. I know who I am.

TOP

返回列表