返回列表 發帖
我比較贊成用退稅方式回饋$6000,另向綜援人仕派發。比較公平。
fibbi 發表於 2011-3-3 15:19


用退稅方式

This would not work, as most Hong Kong people do not need to pay taxes. Those who need to pay, only pay very little.

TOP

本帖最後由 peter236 於 2011-3-3 16:13 編輯
回復  peter236


    You have any stats to support your claim? What is "very little tax"? HK has lo ...
fibbi 發表於 2011-3-3 16:09

The stats can be obtained from Hong Kong government. It is a known fact. There is no need to argue here. Most of the people who pay tax only need to pay little.

TOP

本帖最後由 peter236 於 2011-3-3 16:17 編輯
回復  peter236


So what? Even people who work and pay little tax, they contribute to the govt inc ...
fibbi 發表於 2011-3-3 16:14


You are actually agreeing with me. 用退稅方式 does not work since most people do not pay taxes. So there is no taxes to be refunded.
Just give everyone straight cash.

TOP

回復  fibbi


    我冇新數碼香港身份證,所以無得攞!
fy789 發表於 2011-3-3 16:17

Just get a new number.

TOP

本帖最後由 peter236 於 2011-3-3 16:24 編輯

Just copy and paste from another website:

Hong Kong tax rates are so low.

The salaries tax rate is the lower of either:

    * 15% of "assessable income" after the deduction of allowances; or


    * A progressive rate levied on "assessable income" after the deduction of allowances. For the 2009/10 tax year onwards, these progressive rates are:
      
          o Nil to HKD40,000 - 2%
          o HKD40,000 to HKD80,000 – 7%
          o HKD80,000 to HKD120,000 – 12%
          o HKD120,000 upwards – 17%


Allowances and Deductions

For the 2009/10 year of assessment, the following allowances are deductible from assessable income for salaries tax purposes:

    * Charitable contributions representing up to 35% of an individual's income after allowable expenses and depreciation allowances or assessable profits.
    * A residential care allowance in respect of a parent or grandparent of up to HKD60,000 per annum.
    * Home loan interest deductions from 2003/4 of up to HKD100,000 in any one year of assessment.
    * A current pension allowance of up to HKD12,000 for each year of assessment, not including contributions made by a self-employed person in respect of his employees.
    * Depreciation allowances on all plant and machinery essential to the production of income subject to salaries tax.
    * A single person's allowance of HKD108,000 (2009/10).
    * A married persons' allowance of HKD2165,000 (2009/10).
    * Child allowances of HKD50,000 for each dependant on the 1st to the 9th child (2009/10).
    * Dependent parent, grandparent,sister, brother sibling (to include more than one where necessary) - allowances HKD30,000 each (2009/10).
    * Dependent disabled person's allowance of HKD60,000 (2009/10).
    * Education allowance of HKD60,000 for any course which educates or assists an employee in his profession.




Just do the calculations, most people do not pay or just pay little taxes.

TOP

本帖最後由 peter236 於 2011-3-3 17:42 編輯
回復  peter236


    No I don't agree with you. I said I prefer tax refund because those people con ...
fibbi 發表於 2011-3-3 16:31


Tax refund does not work, since most people do not need to pay taxes. There is no tax or little tax to refund. Hong Kong is not Canada.
Please learn more about Hong Kong.

The most needy people in Hong Kong make less than $60,000 per year. But the personal allowance is already about $100,000, so they do not pay taxes, so no tax to refund.
Therefore, straight cash is a good way to help the most needy people.

Just do the calculations yourself.

TOP

本帖最後由 peter236 於 2011-3-3 18:38 編輯
你條粉腸又幾時變成忽然贊成派錢嘅人?之前我話要派錢,你唔係一直唱反調嘅咩?

正契弟...見保皇黨轉呔就 ...
Lik 發表於 2011-3-3 18:17

hahaha, you are just a moron.
I didn't say giving out cash is necessarily good for Hong Kong's budget or for Hong Kong future.
But if Hong Kong wants to give out cash, then the "straight cash" method is better than "tax refund" method.

TOP

睇你轉呔個死人樣仲快過變面。

正契弟!

-力
Lik 發表於 2011-3-3 18:42

Mr Lik 條英國仔正契弟,自以為事,人又吋,把口又臭, 自己就係PK仔喇.

TOP

亞爺叫你學中文?
sheep 發表於 2011-3-3 19:11


Your British masters taught you English. how much did they pay you?

TOP

返回列表