快樂牛郎

I never call myself a film expertsheep 發表於 2009/5/27 08:28

You never called yourself an expert, but you said you have more experience watching films than other people who are younger.

for me, art is not about experience.
it's how talented you are and your natural appreciation towards beauty.

快樂牛郎

Art is all about creativity, not about experience, I totally agree.
If you want to paint a portrait, your imagination is vital yet you need the technique to express it.
Then, your experience is....... ...
sheep 發表於 2009/5/27 09:14

Yes.
Anne Hui was already making movies when Danny boyle was still in diapers.

快樂牛郎

I welcome all meaningful and constructive comments but I don't see that many on this forum.

快樂牛郎

28# 快樂牛郎


欢迎但不能接受
sheep 發表於 2009/5/28 21:59

Agreeing or disagreeing depends on whether I share the same values as the commentator.  Apparently you and I look at cinema differently and have different asthetics.  You might have a lot of hands on experience, but as a viewer and a cinephile I don't have to agree with the things you have said.

Personally I hate films that aim to lighten up the viewers but with no substance.  But if you enjoy them, that's fine by me.