返回列表 發帖
this is a hoax.  search google.

TOP

http://www.hoax-slayer.com/fake-eggs-china.shtml

there are a lot of fake stuff in China, but not this one.

唔使坳.

TOP

feel free to choose to believe whatever you want.

I'm not a chinese defender/crusader.

TOP

anyway, don't want to argue ... but I choose to believe it is not true simply because

a) making a fake egg that's good enough to fool people is NOT cheap nor easy.  It's based on my experience in building/molding plastic models.   
b) the last step to form the egg shell requires the egg white to be solid already.
c) the demo shows fried eggs sunny side up.  which means the egg white remains liquid.
b) and c) simply contradicts.
e) the final step, even if the egg shell forms, it's not going to be smooth.  don't tell me they  sand it.  the sand paper is worth more $.

If the eggs are sold as cook "tea leaf/soya eggs", I believe it's doable.

again, believe what you want.

TOP

原帖由 cmmm 於 2008-11-27 12:44 發表
I had a really good friend who went to China on a family trip (she told me this personally, so it's not hearsay or anything).  They bought some eggs from the local market to cook at home...  And she s ...



she probably bought 三聚氰胺 eggs.  the egg farmers fed the chicken with too much 三聚氰胺 as a protein supplement and the eggs end up having it.

it was reported in HK last week i think.

TOP

simply put:

"1粒無殼雞蛋便緩緩浮現。將裸蛋定型1小時,以清水沖洗後晾乾,準備上殼"

so the 裸蛋 is solid.  that's without the shell.

"用縫衣線穿過雞蛋,浸入以蜜蠟、碳酸鈣等調製成的蛋殼溶液中,反覆數次,待外殼稍微風乾後,浸入冷水中抽線定型,至此,假雞蛋已穿上外衣,大功告成。"

shell is formed; but the whole thing is a solid shell with solid (定型) fill.

unless something chemically changes, the 裸蛋 egg white is not liquid.  

When that egg is cracked it will just be like a COOK egg, and not able to do sunny side up.

TOP

then the step 清水沖洗後晾乾 can't be valid either.

on top ... if it melts in room temperature and but then solidify when fried ... I'm not a chemist or food scientist.  may be they can confirm the chemical properties of the 2 listed ingredients.

I just have too many question marks regarding the whole procedure and the economy is just not making sense.  that procedure isn't mechanized so it will take a lot of time to make so little $.

i do believe chemically polluted/modified eggs like 三聚氰胺 eggs are entirely possible.

[ 本帖最後由 daimo 於 2008-11-27 13:30 編輯 ]

TOP

SB, I can't see how that instruction is different from the chinese version.

"transfer the egg yolk into the plastic mode that already contain the egg white and soak into liquid calcium chloride to stabilise the shape"

sounds easy, but i can't imagine how it is done easily with stable and consistent  results.

don't want to quote again but i don't want to cut-paste other people's work either.

http://www.hoax-slayer.com/fake-eggs-china.shtml

they even have the same picture from your instruction.

enough said for the day ... believe in what you want.

TOP

http://consumerist.com/consumer/ ... na-style-257693.php

that page as the exact same instruction as yours, SB.

read the line just below:

UPDATE: It's possible this story is a hoax. BoingBoing compared believing it to believing in eBayed unicorns.

TOP

三聚氰胺 was in the chinese food industry for a good couple of years.

back then they didn't know what 三聚氰胺 really was.

TOP

返回列表