返回列表 發帖
Theoretically yes, Practical no... Far too expensive to travel inside vacuum tubes... Better to take it on planes instead...

TOP

本帖最後由 lo_pak 於 2010-9-15 15:32 編輯

The higher the speed, the more constraints... $32.49M/km is not an estimate, it's rather a "guessimate" (and a poor one, IMO). The superconductor used on magnetic trains are too expensive and the technology is still not mature... In order to travel at 1000km/hr, most tracks have to be on pretty straight sections, terrain detour to avoid building tunnels didn't work ($$$). Maintaining vacuum pipeline is another challenge, in ground level it's still okay (but still costly though); once you are underground, that's another story, my guess is you have to build a double hull structure, ie. tunnel inside tunnel, whereas the outermost tunnel is at normal pressure and the inside tunnel is under vacuum... That's why I think it should cost way more...

And, in order to maintain the pipeline in vacuum, there should be many gates along the way. At 1000km/hr = 277m/sec, even if you set the gates at 10km interval (have you ever seen a vacuum pipe that's 10km long??), from gate to gate it spends only 36 secs. Imagine if there's a gate malfunction, what would happen? OK, let's say you are having an emergency stop, you are decelerating at 1G (free falling force just like you are jumping out of a building), you need almost 14secs travelling for almost 4km to complete stop...

TOP

本帖最後由 lo_pak 於 2010-9-15 22:50 編輯

回復 5# peter236

I beg you should study harder when you are young...
Even a high school student can get these numbers within minutes, nothing fancy, it's only Newton's Laws of Motion...
I'm not talking about superconducting and aerodynamics... already...

If it's economical, magnetic train would have been popularized since it's invented couple decades ago by the Germans (The best mechanical engineer group on earth). The technology is always there, it's just a matter of fact if it can be done in an effective and efficient way...

TOP

回復 3# peter236

The $32.49M unit cost per km is really a joke...
For US, the unit cost is +/- $110M;
For Japan, the unit cost is +/- $100M;
Those data were from 2003 estimate, and those are based on "regular" magnetic train track...
For China Shanghai one, the unit cost is +/- $40M in 2002.

TOP

返回列表