返回列表 發帖
Big C Sister, I think they are trying to say that the rental yield in Vancouver sucks. Aka. people are making very little money, if at all, renting out their property, especially if the property is on leverage.

I don't know if people are making or losing money over renting out places they have mortgaged, but the Vancouver market surely sucks in terms of rental yield. What more? If the general mind-set of Vancovuerite is to mortgage a place and rent it out, then no wonder why the rent here sucks. This also sounds like a highly leveraged real estate bubble still waiting to burst.

http://www.globalpropertyguide.c ... anada/Rental-Yields

Back to the topic. I think it's difficult to 上車 right now. It's unaffordable and not an attractive investment, regardless if it's 自住 or not. It's basically buying at peak. Don't know if it'll drop like a tank any time soon, but I definately ain't worried about another big leg running up in RE prices in Vancouver. As it is right now, it's probably better to rent than buy for now, if one doesn't have "parent's place" to crash.

TOP

回復 32# 大C姐

I think we have been talking about rental yield here, not rental prices.

Of course if the overal housing prices goes up, rental prices will be forced to go up too. However if housing price increase is going up a lot faster than rental affordability, it will only means that the rental yield will be pushed down even lower.

Aka, if a house is $600k and the rent is $2000, that's 4% annualized yield. Say housing goes up as you said, to $700k say next year. The rent have to go up of course, but it wont' be by as much as a percentage as the housing cost, because there's simply less enthusiasm in the rental market as compared to the housing market. Say the rent is increased to $2200, which to the renter who barely had a raise last year, a huge increase. The home owner doesn't get all the pricing flexibility here either, the renter will threaten leave and rent at Abbortsford if he has to, simply because he just doesn't have that much money. $2200 on $700k, that's an annualized yield of 3.77%. So the rent went up, and the yield went down.

The argument that when housing cost (home prices/taxes/interest, etc) going up, it'd force home buyers to rent, hence pushing up rental rate, is not a sure thing, and in most historical precedence false. It'd usually take a larger increase in housing prices, so much so to significantly force would-be buyers to rent. The rental price hike as a percentage will generally be less than the increase of housing prices in such cases, hence actually reducing rental yield, instead of increasing it. Affordability is simply too much a barrier to put much upward pressure on rental prices, as it's the locals that work for 32k a year that rents, which is rather inelastic compared to the seemingly infinite wealth that foriegn investors and immigrants have in buying up houses.

It's very simple to see. As the Vancouver housing prices heats up, rental yield goes down. This is the effect of foreign demand bidding up prices and the local, whose earning power stays constant, turns to renting cheaper and cheaper places based on affordability.

TOP

Not against Big C Sister or anything... I usually like her posts as a good laugh. But we really have to move on from this one this time. It's really enough said after 14 pages...

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-7-16 18:01 編輯

Sometimes I see that people view buying a place as some virtuous financial goal of a life-time. 上車 is viewed as some sacred achievement by some. It's okay to adopt such a viewpoint, but only if one recognizes the countering viewpoints. From my narrow observations, there are usually 2 reasons for a single individual (not maried/common-law etc) to buy a place
1. Housing is an awesome investment in the long term (20 years - 30 years time frame), even if one'd have negative real rental yield (minus inflation, interest and other maintenance and management costs). Capital appreciation will always trump the negative yield.
2. Owning a place and moving out to live by oneself is a need. As soon as you can afford it one shall do so right away.

For 1, I personally think that people are influenced by the prior generation, and history of the past 20-30 years into thinking that real estate is the ultimate investment in terms of risk/return. For most people that are born post 1950's, housing boom have been with them through-out all their lives. They have gotten accustom to the boom and think that perpetual housing price increase, on the long term, it's a law of physics. So it doesn't matter even if one have bought at peak. They'd think that any counter example are exceptions, not the norm, and will surely catch back up if the investment horizon is sufficiently long. I personally have reservation in this line of view point.

For 2, I personally think that living by oneself is a luxury, not a need. If buying a place and renting it out is not an attractive investment, then buying a place and living by oneself is simply a luxury spending. The money that's sunk in interest, maintenance, property tax obviously would be pricey, but at least can be viewed as a cost of investment. But compared to living with parents or siblings, you are basically doubling all the other costs, on things such as buying groceries, phone bill, TV bill, internet bill, etc etc. Those are definately avoidable luxury spending that doesn't contribute to the investment in the hope of real estate capital appreciation.

Obviously, different people value things differently. I myself, as a single individual, just doesn't find the need to buy a place, nor do I think it's a good investment. I consider it as a very overpriced luxury item that I don't want to spend my money on. So it's not 易上車 or 難上車. To me, it's just 唔低買. In such light, the topic of the thread already seemed to be skewed towards the side that "one must buy a place, it's either u can afford it or not afford it". Which IMO is just very narrow visioned, biased and simply incorrect.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-7-17 01:29 編輯
回復  大C姐


    但係呢邊低極就算variable都無prime-1 啦
fibbi 發表於 2010-7-16 23:28


Happy Cow said IF you can fix at 4%, then mortgage is a good option. Obviously as you guys pointed out, you can't fix it at 4%. Hence mortgage is not a good option.

Just merely from this post, I can see how people blindly think that buying houses is always a positive, and that my observation as outlined in my previous post is quite accurate.

I don't know why you people think Happy Cow is a youngster. The investment wisdom he demonstrated from his posts is one of the best I have seen from almost any LYK who have posted. Investing yourself is always going to be the best investment you can ever make. It's the most liquid and least susceptible to depreciation and macro economic conditions. Possibly some reference to Buffet's interview from last November also~

In terms of assets, commodities is also probably going to be a good bet. Houses, at current valuation have very low alpha IMO. I think the financial professor in the Globe and Mail video that CP posted have it quite right on. There's an emotional attachment into buying houses, hence over-inflating and producing this euphoria on real estate prices. The negative stigma associated with rental is exactly what makes rent a better proposition than buying, at least for a lot more situations than we traditionally suspect.

TOP

回復  大C姐


    另外個thread我都有提過,投資嘅$應該係你認為蝕哂都無問題嘅先好去投。就算匯豐,都 ...
fibbi 發表於 2010-7-16 22:34


I think it should be, if you are trading, you should expect to lose it all.
When it comes to investment, it should be all your money. Investment should mean a conscious way of deploying your savings into causes that will provide return. Investing definitely does not mean doing day trade on the stock market.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-7-17 02:09 編輯
回復  Catpiano


    果條蛋散偏激左啦... 我留翻俾其他人回啦。

我仲有一個故事想分享。

好幾年前岩岩 ...
大C姐 發表於 2010-7-16 22:01


Don't really understand why you think he is a 蛋散 and is 偏激. Not to mention that he have a very good case, with rational (instead of emotional) analysis in supporting his argument, not just based on some individual example or the past trend. Besides, he is a finance professor, your credential, miss?

And your story about 2 couples making 80k having 2 houses... is really just an individual case. How about HK first time home buyers that suicided because of negative equities in the house back during SARS? I know a lot of people (esp my parent's generation) making truck loads from real estates. There are also people that made boat loads trading the stock market. Individual cases definitely does not reflect the average across the world, nationality and time-scale. Past performance is not a very good indicator of future performance either.

TOP

我估你好細個囉。你都未眼巴巴經歷過咩係生老病死...

我當然明你要invest in yourself﹐但係同買唔 ...
大C姐 發表於 2010-7-16 22:37


A full time B School in a half-good school in the states or Europe would easily cost double of what a 20% downpayment would take... Law School or Med School will take substantially more. I don't see how investing in yourself (if in the form of education at least) would not interfere with investing in assets like a house, which not only have high opportunity cost but also usually ties you down at a certain geographical location, especially when we are saying that houses is only a moderately reasonable option if you live in it yourself.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-7-17 01:58 編輯
回復  快樂牛郎


    咁咩analysis都係睇past trend架啦。你又難保next 30 年啲樓一定會跌?不過,我明嘅 ...
fibbi 發表於 2010-7-16 22:18


I think the problem with buying a place in Vancouver is not return, it's risk. Valuation is plainly inflated. Analysis that base only on past performance is some of the worst analysis. Learn about investment analysis and you'd realize is more than just gambling based on past trend or other technical indicators.

TOP

This really depends on an individual basis so I am glad you mentioned that you personally think it ...
biggie 發表於 2010-7-16 19:46


I always think that my parents would like if I stay around the house at least a little bit of the time. How boring is it if it's just the two of them? I always feel kind of bad if I just move out and abandon them now that i can afford to move out/buy a house, etc. So it's a win-win. There's some sacrifices in my privacy, but I can afford that short coming.

Of course, one should pay some allowance/help with some expense around the house, so it's not free leaching. But for surely, the total expense between parents + u living under the same roof, vs your parents under one roof + you under another roof, should definitely be less and thus more economical overall.

TOP

返回列表