返回列表 發帖
17 pages in less than 48 hours, and I missed this whole exchange? LOL. Lucky me LOL XDD

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-9-28 17:53 編輯

60k isn't even average income for a single person....

If someone with 60k have to live that miserably to afford a mortgage (barely on a beater car, no emergency cash, can't save more than 10%, can't contribute a penny to RRSP by that calculation, etc), then the average person definately cannot afford anything within Vancouver - hence Unaffordable for the average Vancouverite. Even Big C Sister admitted that someone with 60k (above average already rmbr) probably wants to buy in suburbs, not in Vancouver. The average pay cheque earning single simply can't buy a place in Vancouver unless they got extended a stupid mortgage.

Any further discussion on this point is a waste of bandwidth. 人地都話 Vancouver 係最 unaffordable in the English speaking world, 仲有必要 discuss whether it's unaffordable 咩? The question should be, WHY is Vancouver so unaffordable? Foreign investment? Bubbled fueled by speculation? Bubble fueled by credit? If the average Canadian can't even touch Vancouver property, who is touching them? Is this sustainable? Those are the real questions to tackle.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-9-28 17:51 編輯
回復  Look4chrisng


    I guess the discussion is $500K property with $60K annual salary is afford ...
fibbi 發表於 2010-9-28 17:21


Good for you if you live frugal. Such spending pattern is simply not the norm. Obviously someone can 'afford' a Ferrari making 60k a year by being very frugal on all other aspects of his/her life. That is simply not the norm, and thus a Ferrari is usually deemd 'unaffordable' by the average person.

Same thing for Vancovuer real estate. Remeber we are not talking about individual cases. Economies and markets are not formed by a few examples, they are formed by the majority. Hence why MSN04 have always been stressing 'statistics' that reflects the majority, not the few fringe cases that you heard about, nor the hypothetical cases that you are putting together. Those are meaningless when it comes to the grand scheme of things.

TOP

回復  BiscottiGelato
    I don't think my case is hypothetical at all. It's all base on numbers.  ...
fibbi 發表於 2010-9-28 18:00


fibbi, you don't understand what statistics mean. Statistics mean what the MAJORITY of people do. Not if your hypothetical number is possible.

Reality is, the majority of the average pay cheque earning Vancouverites find houses in Vancouver unaffordable. It's as simple as that. You numbers might work for you (probably doesn't even work for yourself tho, if I am to place a bet), but probably won't work for most Vancouverites.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-9-30 16:57 編輯

The world works more according to the charts, much more so than a couple people's intuition... It's just like going to the casino, the odd is against you and you know you'll lose money most of the time. You might feel 'lucky' that day, you might even come out winning money. But the odd is against you nevertheless. You can still do it, but all I can say is to wish you luck...

With the instability on the HST, economy slowing, interest rate con't to go up, plenty of inventories coming online. Down side risk is much higher than upside risk. The probability that there'll be a 55% drop from the recent peak before ever getting to 55% up from the peak is much much much higher than the other way around. If one can stomach that, then a property now is definately no problem. Short of that, just understand the risk before committing yourself in buying any real estates, or you might face unexpected hardship down the road.

It's really quite simple I don't understand why people don't understand. When buying, try to buy low. When selling, try to sell high. Is the Vancouver market considered high? or low? Don't let greed run over your head, don't let the trend deceive you that this is the exception to the norm. Mean reversion always take place, not being able to predict when it'll happen does not mean that it will not happen. It will most likely happen when you can least afford it.

TOP

好似股市,大跌市你敢唔敢買?低處未算低。何況如果突然大跌市好可能係啲金融風暴類似嘅問題,百物銷條到時 ...
fibbi 發表於 2010-9-30 23:30


From the tone of 牛郎, 佢等待左呢日好耐, LOL. Probably tons of cash equivilent waiting to invest. Probably snipe up stock, house, everything at that point LOL.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-10-1 13:53 編輯
but the RE still worth 85%
sheep 發表於 2010-10-1 13:24


If you have 20%/30% paid off on the house...
- A 20/30% drop on the home would've wiped the equity in your home out. Aka, if you sell your home, whether it be forced to sell or sell voluntarily, u'd be penniless.
- If there's a greater than 20/30% drop on the home, you'd be under water. I don't know if the bank would make you make up the difference or foreclose your property. Regardless, you'd be in a negative equity position, if not outright bankruptcy...

Say someone put 20% down on a home with a 30 years mortgage. Keeping in mind that in the initial stint, most of the payment probably won't be contributed into the equity of the home (aka only towards interest). For convinience, lets say for the first 5 years, all the payments are on interest reduction. That means, the equity portion in the home would continue to be 20% if the market price stayed flat. If the market price tanked by 20% or more in the next 5 years, one would have 0 equity, or negative equity in the property... If one's in an unfortunate position that they need a big chunk of emergency cash, and thought they can count on selling the home to get some equity, etc.... there'd be no equity to tap into. obviously savings have all gone in as Mortgage payment already (esp with some of the calculations fibbi was doing where all spare cash went into mortgage payment). it's essentially over for this individual...

Bet he/she wish that he/she just paid rent and kept the money.....

That's why I said, if one can bear (pun intended )a mean reversion to the long term trend line, or even an overshot below the long term trend line, buy a home, live in it, and be happy you are not paying someone else's mortgage. If a mean reversion (35% drop or so?) means you'd be in the red, then you definately should not buy a place, whether you think you can afford the mortgage payment or not. As happy cow said, you are doing a 500% leverage, imagine doing that on stocks. The risk is the same thing if you are buying real estate at all time high at multi-fold leverage levels.

TOP

You're 100% right. I think every home owner understands the risks involved.

BUT, if the real ...
大C姐 發表於 2010-10-1 15:31


Again, do you agree that there's more of a downside risk (a possible drop) than an upside risk (price running away from this point)? If not there's almost no point in talking about this because essentially the conception is that housing will go up forever, even at the current peak point.

Now, if you do think downside risk is considerable that it justisfies further thinking into the matter, then we must look at how big a drop we'd expect if the risk materializes. We are at a minimum 35% over the historic long term trend (30-50 years trend). We must factor in this risk when we determine whether one can afford  a place.

So yes, if the downside risk is reasonably quantified and factored into the affordability equation, and one can still afford to buy, then I agree with you in the recommendation that people should buy what they can afford now. My suspicion is that with a 35% downside risk factored in, most should conclude that this is not the time to buy, even if it means renting for now and having to put up with the overhead of moving later.

My personal investment thesis for majority of my portfolio is to beat inflation and counter downside risk (capital preservation). A massive deflation would bold well for my position. I am not very concerned about certain trends emerges and take off on me. Greed is good but I try to keep it reasonably in check. Moreover, historically, housing prices tend to be more affected by the local economy than the global one. If the local economy under performs the global economy, a well diversed portfolio will most probably out perform the local housing value, especially at current valuations. So will many non-service oriented jobs survive if it's just the local economy going into the drain.

TOP

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2010-10-4 10:11 編輯
金融風暴/開嘯果陣﹐好多小市民都無cash架嘛。你儲錢放入銀行咩﹗若然突然跌市﹐你會唔會蝕住賣股票 ...
大C姐 發表於 2010-10-1 22:20


That's why the perspective is skewed. Chinese/Honger are hardly the norm in the Canadian housing market. I don't think the majority on this forum are the kind that have plenty of foreign investments and assets in HK. I think the majority are more like the average Canadians, working locally with majority of their assets in the country (or at max, in the US). Besides, if the global economy tanks, the most likely scenario is USD/HKD rise against CAD... so ones with assets in HK would be able to afford more real-estates in Canada with the same money anyways.

Besides, the argument that one won't have the cash to downpay is non-sense. If someone have the money to put in as down payment now, if he/she chooses to do so, can easily put it in some safer investments and enter the housing market at a more favorable entry point later. If one doesn't have the money for downpayment now, then he/she can't possibly enter the market now anyways. Either way, there's nothing that bounds someone to not being able to enter the market later, esp if he/she can afford to enter the market now.

TOP

仲有講多句。

有D人話而家買樓﹐leverage點高點高﹐我個人經驗而言﹐同樓市高低係無咩關係。

假設你原本 ...
大C姐 發表於 2010-10-1 23:23


I don't know if that's necassarily the case. I think the low housing affordability definatley makes people pay a bigger portion of their income towards accomodations. If housing are more affordable, I am sure there are more people than not that's going to go for a cheaper place.

Aka. If a Studio is going for 250k now, and prices dropped such that a Studio is 180k instead, with 2 bedrooms going for 250k. I think people will probably buy a bigger place than a studio, but would probably go for a 1 bedroom at say, 210k. In general, leverage should go down. This is especially true for a market where affordability is very poor. Regardless, for the Vancouver market, leverage will definately not stay constant if housing prices cools down.

TOP

返回列表