siumaibb

唔錯，如果專心唱歌就可能有一番成就

matt72178

嘩~~~索~~~Thanks~

yayaya

I LIKE HER STYLE TOO

大C姐

7# shutterbug


當然﹐好唔好向來係見人見智。有D人個表準set得好高。但係呢個係entertainment industry﹐Ella算係一個典型靚女唱得OK已經係叫做賞心悅目﹐絕唔會係慘不忍睹卦?

Littleprince

我都好欣賞Ella, 不過唔知點解佢好似唔係好紅得起....

creamy 發表於 2009-4-2 22:12

我猜是經理人的問題﹖ 若有好的經理人應該可以成功。。。

像鷹黃的那些﹐完全唔掂都可以紅﹐證明包裝好重要﹐ 肯DUMP錢落去碰亦係關鍵。。。

Catpiano

Yeah ..  Ella is hot ..  

So ..   now we got the idea ..  Big C sister ..  looks like ELLA ?

peter236

我猜是經理人的問題﹖ 若有好的經理人應該可以成功。。。

像鷹黃的那些﹐完全唔掂都可以紅﹐證明包裝好重要﹐ 肯DUMP錢落去碰亦係關鍵。。。
Littleprince 發表於 2009-4-3 19:34

If you listen to Ella's singing, which is quite good, but still no match for Miriam Yeung and Joey Yung. Miriam and Joey can really sing and perform on stage. They are successful for a reason.

大C姐

17# peter236


楊千嬅我覺得係女歌手中最幸運一個﹐出道至今真係好多好有水準又好岩佢唱嘅作品。當然可能人緣加工司力捧啦。我唔係話楊千嬅無努力﹐當然我都好認欣賞佢嘅作風﹐都好有character同好charming。但係唱左十幾年﹐緊係好啦﹐唔係都接埋啦﹐唔通賣樣麼。

Catpiano

Oh ..  that case, I am totally agree with big c sister ..  

楊千嬅我覺得係女歌手中最幸運一個 ..

She is .. bay far .. not pretty ...  not even close .. ( um ..  not ugly gei .. )   

No figure ......  

No good voice ...  

No good singing skill ..  

No dance ..



Basically ..  ZERO  " pros "  

However, she got some good songs ..   her singing may be just average .. normal karaoke standard ..  ( again, not that bad, slightly better then vivian chow la.. )

I still dont get it, why 楊千嬅 is (was) so popular ..  but I guess, luck + timing. And 52% people in HK are women ..  they like to see such as AVERAGE girl become a STAR .. however, for guys ??   we dont appreciate 楊千嬅 style la....  

(Even Sammy ..  not the best, but luck + hard working + not bad look + quite good sining)

peter236

17# peter236


楊千嬅我覺得係女歌手中最幸運一個﹐出道至今真係好多好有水準又好岩佢唱嘅作品。當然可能人緣加工司力捧啦。我唔係話楊千嬅無努力﹐當然我都好認欣賞佢嘅作風﹐都好有character同好charming。但係 ...
大C姐 發表於 2009-4-3 21:25

Miriam Yeung is a very good singer. She came from New Talent Singing Awards competition, so she has a certain standard of singing. She does not depend on her looks or figures, unlike Ella. Only immature fans will look for a nice figure in a singer. We are talking about singing skills, not a beauty pageant.

Joey Yung, on the other hand, can sing an dance well on the stage. Again, she does not need to depend on her looks or figures. She is one of the few female singers who can really entertain the audiences on the stage. Therefore, she is the queen of Cantopop right now.

It is hard to spot a rising star. Even if you can find a pretty girl who can sing, who knows how to play the piano, like GEM, still there is no gaurantee that she will succeed.