HST has good motive but at the bad time, because it hurts spending in a slow economy.
HST is good fo ...
Prelude 發表於 2011-4-23 21:50
" The point is, to keep the hst or not, still hurts us at the current situation. But since we suffered half of the disadvantage already, we might as well suffer of the remaining half to gain the benefit of HST in the future."
So say hi to lucky Layton, the king-maker
somewhereintime 發表於 2011-4-24 17:55
In the last 2 governments, Layton has played the King-maker role to its maximum potential. But now that the NDP's support is slightly higher than the Liberals', it makes me wonder if he can continue to play this opportunistic role.
As the official Opposition party, you can't just rely on landing the same old cheap shots when the opponent is looking the other way.
According to Layton, we have the option of eliminating HST without coughing it out.
IFF Layton has his way, one way or the other
That is: 1. He became the PM and the NDP rules Canada for the next 4 years
2. He became the Leader of the coalition gov't 3. In the case of another minority government, he can blackmail the gov't to push that policy
Also, there is conceptual question, which is, the argument is that business will save money by HST thus the extra money will go to workers. Is that true? will it be true? I doubt.
Of course the HST has its advantage.
1.) Much easier to calculate.
2.) Less confusion = increase spending (only little effects though)
3.) Reduce government staff
4.) Attract big companies = more jobs = more spending
Disadvantages:
1.) Increase total price of spending. 7% increase affects much more than 7% decrease in spending, because people's demand/price ratio is not linear.
2.) Chinese restaurant pockets more tax money.
3.) On the edge of closing restaurants see this as a final blow, along with all the "anti-restaurants" policies/law in this 4 years.
4.) Crazy inflation + increase tax is not good combination.
Again, long term effects is good, but it's the timing that's not good.
Some say the way Campbell put it down our throat is bad, but no one likes taxes. If they ask for our opinion before adding tax, do you think it will ever go through? Never will.
I would say the best way to handle this is reduce it by 1% or 2%, people will love it. But I heard that part of the deal from federal government is that the rate can't be changed within 1 year, not sure it's true or not.