Catpiano

BRAVO !!!

Catpiano

Not bad ...  but not as good as she used to be ..

However, Aaron was bad ..  so when compare, Shirley is much better la..

Catpiano

Too bad her personality is kind of weird...cannot become a big star...a waste!
shutterbug 發表於 2010-10-15 11:10

Yeah .. even she may not better then Faye Wong/Sandy/Anita/Sally etc ..

But by far better then Yeung Chin Wah ... and better then Sammy etc ..

Catpiano

There is no way she is better than Sammy.
peter236 發表於 2010-10-16 02:41

    I am talking about her voice, and singing, not as an actress/star.

Don't tell me you think Sammy's voice and singing skill is better then Shirley ...

Say Andy Lau is a super star, but is he a good singer??

As ECkwok said, 楊千嬅係香港樂壇一個奇蹟 (plus LUCK).. but in HK .. (even other countries) having good voice, not always success ...