My understanding is that while the residents there are not natives (原居民), many have been living there for decades. In fact, some have been living there for 2 generations. Despite the extended period in which they've resided at the village, they don't enjoy much of the benefits that are available to NT 原居民. But I do believe they have the proper land ownership rights, although the land there are classified mostly for agricultural use.
The problem is, after forcing through the legislation to demolish the village despite massive protests, high ranking ministers have promised the villagers a combination fair settlement, relocation of the residents, and rebuilding of the village at an alternative location. Unfortunately, when the villages actually try to contact various bureaus and offices for compensation application / evaluation, they were at first treated as 人球, being bounced around between different ministries. For ones that actually looked at the applications, an incredible and unreasonably amount of bureaucracy were dumped onto the villagers. At times, the bureaucratic work were directly contradictory to what the high ranking minister have promised the villagers (eg. definition of farming / agricultural activities). In other instances, the bureau contradicted their own earlier words (eg. proof of residence status). Terms of settlement were also utterly unfair. One notable example was that 1960-era monetary figures were used directly as compensation numbers for the villagers agricultural products. (Think think how much veggies cost back in 1960 and how much they cost now).
Worst of all, the HKSAR government is insisting on clearing the villagers out despite their previous promise of compensating the villagers and relocating them + rebuilding the village at a different location. Many of the remaining villagers have no means to re-settle, so when they get kicked out of their own homes, it is unclear where they will live.
As I have posted previously, there is a very detailed first-hand account of the villagers' sufferings and unfair treatment available from the Internet program since Nov 11:
http://www.hkreporter.com/channel_list.php?channelid=257
There are accusations that villagers and support groups are milking the government compensation packages for all they are worth. I certainly would not doubt that abuses exists, and that some of the parties involved have more than altruistic motives. But it all goes back to the moral and belief system that you have because no system is perfect. Would you rather have 寧縱莫枉 or 寧枉莫縱?
I am a firm believer of innocent until proven guilty, and I would rather let 10 guilty people get away instead of accusing a single innocent victim.
-Lik |