tiffiant

what would the consequence if you talk to them.......

Ultraman

原帖由 tiffiant 於 2009-2-8 12:57 發表
what would the consequence if you talk to them.......

You see a guy is going to steal/stealing money from a gal's purse.....
You see a guy is going to rape/raping a gal.....
You see a guy is going to stab/stabbing a gal.....
.
.
.
.
what would be the consequence if you talk to/stop them.......

Now you see the mother is helping her little kid to pee inside the MTR train cabin, what would be the consequence if you talk to/stop them?

tiffiant

what happen if the mother yells you
will you argue back with theM?

tiffiant

You see a guy is going to steal/stealing money from a gal's purse.....
You see a guy is going to rape/raping a gal.....
You see a guy is going to stab/stabbing a gal.....


that's different......if a GUY doing harm to anyone,
i bet some ppl would STOP the GUY

Ultraman

原帖由 tiffiant 於 2009-2-8 13:38 發表
You see a guy is going to steal/stealing money from a gal's purse.....
You see a guy is going to rape/raping a gal.....
You see a guy is going to stab/stabbing a gal.....


that's different......if a GUY doing harm to anyone,
i bet some ppl would STOP the GUY

Same situation here, people thought there would be some people stopping the mother, in fact nobody did.
If, someone is doing something that is going to harm/hurt another (for example holding a knife in hand), there would be a risk for people go interrupting the situation for being harm/hurt as well. But now how could the mother or the little kid is gonna harm/hurt you? The most maybe the kid would pee on you or the mother yell at you. Do you really get hurt? However, it's up to one's righteous and moral standard and value whether how you (a general "you") would react in those kind of situations.

tiffiant

the kid pees into the gap, how does the pee harm your body? maybe smell? but the pee smell doesn't really existed like obstacles - (dont' know how to spell the word)(don't know if i spell right)

workers in MTR should be responsible for this....
workers are responsible the safety of the passengers

tiffiant

法律的定義很霧糊

Ultraman

原帖由 tiffiant 於 2009-2-8 15:15 發表
the kid pees into the gap, how does the pee harm your body? maybe smell? but the pee smell doesn't really existed like obstacles - (dont' know how to spell the word)(don't know if i spell right)

workers in MTR should be responsible for this....
workers are responsible the safety of the passengers

I meant, and as you said, people would help if they see something "might harm their bodies" such as seeing a guy pointing a knife at a gal to rob or something; but now peeing is not going to harm you (as you said), then why people don't stop it?
So, you think peeing into the gap (between the train cabin and the platform) but not really inside the train cabin is OK?
According to what you said, it's MTR staffs' responsibility for that situation, can I say it's cops' responsibility to stop crime, so regular citizens need not to do anything even they see crime thing happens?
For the MTR case, isn't it every single passenger's responsibility to keep the train cabin, and the platform, and the corresponding area clean?

starbug

原帖由 Lik 於 2009-2-8 10:33 發表

At work again?我想請問你，條片係咪假嘅呢？係咪小弟生按白做，自己請演員去拍嘅呢？我係咪好似你咁，收人地五毫子一個 post 呢？內地同胞響地鐵小便又同英國有乜野關係呢？

-力 ...

咁我明啦, 阿Toppy絛粉腸梗係又收人地五毫子一個 post嘅.

tiffiant

原帖由 Ultraman 於 2009-2-8 18:33 發表

I meant, and as you said, people would help if they see something "might harm their bodies" such as seeing a guy pointing a knife at a gal to rob or something; but now peeing is not going to harm you ...

if a person is not a MTR worker
and this situation, Will he/she talk to the mother/ or talk to MTR workers
ppl don't want to get involve of any cases/situations....because they have to go to court/police station to report...
and really messing up their time......

if harmful, ppl must help right away instead ignoring someone
how would one feel if you talk to the mother.....
will the mother continue to let the kid pee at other stations