rainbow-davie

我自問未做到，
今世已經績下好多孽
我有法名嗟。。。。
但係仲鍾意食佛跳牆，未咁快看破呀～ LOL
B仔 發表於 2009-12-17 10:21

法名is 佛跳牆?

shutterbug

冇。你仲係輪迴。
因為成佛就已脫離la
B仔 發表於 2009-12-17 13:38

Still don't understand, can you elaborate?

We knew from some "history" that 釋迦牟尼 was a prince before he became Buddha.  Is there another person who became Buddha besides him?  He had disciples, any of his disciples  became Buddha?

If nobody since then can become Buddha, doesn't this kind of mean whatever you do or not do you cannot become Buddha?  Only the founder can be Buddha?  That seems a little strange.

shutterbug

冇。你仲係輪迴。
因為成佛就已脫離la
B仔 發表於 2009-12-17 13:38

Still don't understand, can you elaborate?

We knew from some "history" that 釋迦牟尼 was a prince before he became Buddha.  Is there another person who became Buddha besides him?  He had disciples, any of his disciples  became Buddha?

If nobody since then can become Buddha, doesn't this kind of mean whatever you do or not do you cannot become Buddha?  Only the founder can be Buddha?  That seems a little strange.

B仔

Can someone that is at 佛 level go back to 作惡?  Can a 佛 ever fail again?
shutterbug 發表於 2009-12-17 13:34

脫離輪迴=冇孽
已經唔o係CYCLE喇

唔同聖經。。。EX：天使FAIL／打落凡間地獄

chunsh

Still don't understand, can you elaborate?

We knew from some "history" that 釋迦牟尼 was a prince before he became Buddha.  Is there another person who became Buddha besides him?  He had disciples,  ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009-12-17 13:10

is there anyone can reach the stage of Buddah is like is there anyone have successfully gone to heaven and took a picture with God or Michael the head of the Archangel or took a picture with Satan in Hell and then put the pics in facebook

shutterbug

is there anyone can reach the stage of Buddah is like is there anyone have successfully gone to heaven and took a picture with God or Michael the head of the Archangel or took a picture with Satan in ...
chunsh 發表於 2009-12-17 14:37

OK, nobody has been to heaven and back (well except Jesus I guess), and since you said achieving Buddha is like that, so ultimately you're saying Buddha is NOT achievable?

So it's like you go to university to study but you can never get a degree...that's very upsetting!

chunsh

OK, nobody has been back to heaven and back (well except Jesus), so you're saying Buddha is NOT achievable?

So it's like you go to university to study but you can never get a degree...that's very up ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009-12-17 14:18

what I am trying to say is, you should think clearly before u questioned / challenged. When u try to challenge that no one can give any prove about being able to reach the stages of Buddah, u seems like u forgot no one can come back to tell he see god or not. so in both cases, there is no any acceptable answer in our physical world. Then how come u believe in god, and saying there are heaven and hell?

Ultraman

OK, nobody has been to heaven and back (well except Jesus I guess), so you're saying Buddha is NOT achievable?

So it's like you go to university to study but you can never get a degree...that's very ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009-12-17 14:18

On the other hand, can you prove there is anyone went to heaven successfully?
Same situation, I don't think we can prove someone went to heaven, nor someone became a buddha. So if no one can give any proof, can I conclude that there is no heaven no Jesus/God no buddha....?

B仔

OK, nobody has been to heaven and back (well except Jesus I guess), and since you said achieving Buddha is like that, so ultimately you're saying Buddha is NOT achievable?

So it's like you go to uni ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009-12-17 15:18

你係輪迴未完，孽未報哂，唔代表NOT ACHIEVABLE。

就算聖經寫到明話信主就會上天堂，教徒可以保證真係上到天堂？
又譬如，神教徒會唔會問，偉大嘅MOTHER THERESA，有冇機會／有資格，做主身邊的天使？

客觀D講，任何宗教信仰嘅AFTER LIFE POV係要嚟安撫你有生之年的心靈。

fibbi

做好自己，after life 嘅嘢，就唔洗理得咁多la, 反正唔係我哋啲人可以揀。你可以揀嘅，就係現在做個好人定衰人。
做好人嘅，天主會睇住（眷顧）你，俾你升天堂;或者佛組會賜你下世比現世更好，掂啲嘅，可能聶盤成佛添，脫離輪迴生死之苦。係咪？
反而，我唔係好明點解好多基督徒話因為想上天堂，而去信天主。好似好有目的喎，點解唔係因為我信天主教嘅教義，相信有耶穌，有天父呢個做物者而去信呢？為咗有得上天堂而信，好似有點兒那個。。。