BiscottiGelato

Girl in Rain
光圈先決 發表於 2009-11-16 17:20

This looks so much like the photo that Tony Hoffer submitted to Rangefinder magazine.
http://www.hofferphotography.com/

shutterbug

I love that one from Tony.  Saw it a few months ago and I can't forget it; it's simply amazing!  He's one of my fav wedding photogs.

Btw Tony was published on Rangefinder Magazine:
http://www.rangefindermag.com/st ... 9_Unsung_Hoffer.pdf

快樂牛郎

I love that one from Tony.  Saw it a few months ago and I can't forget it; it's simply amazing!  He's one of my fav wedding photogs.

Btw Tony was published on Rangefinder Magazine:
http://www.rangefi ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009/11/19 12:23

The idea might be similar but the execution is......

btw Rangefinder is a pretty good magazine to have for free

BiscottiGelato

The idea might be similar but the execution is......

btw Rangefinder is a pretty good magazine to have for free
快樂牛郎 發表於 2009-11-19 13:37

Well, of course Hoffer's was both a wonderful idea and excellent execution. Doing something like this in the middle of a live wedding is definately something else.

But I'd have to say 光圈先決's attempt isn't bad at all. Not as sharp due to digital scanning instead of straight from a DSLR, but not bad at all, at least to me with my low standards.

Rangefinder mag is free? Where do you find it for free???

快樂牛郎

Well, of course Hoffer's was both a wonderful idea and excellent execution. Doing something like this in the middle of a live wedding is definately something else.

But I'd have to say 光圈先決's at ...
BiscottiGelato 發表於 2009/11/19 15:58

https://rangerinder-sub.halldata ... ew/init.do?&PK=

I am not saying 光圈先決's photo is poor.  I just don't think it's appropriate to compare the two photos, because 光圈先決 might have a different idea in mind when he shot that photo.

Just judging 光圈先決's photo on its own, I do like the background a lot, but the girl looks rather flat, like it's pasted on top in photoshop.

Catpiano

I somehow thing that 光圈先決's photo is very good ..  dont know how to make that kind of background ..  ( rain? + light? )

At least, one of the best picture posted in this forum .. IMO

光圈先決

GIR II

BiscottiGelato

GIR II
光圈先決 發表於 2009-11-19 23:40

mind to share how this is done? The bright light on the right is at an angle semi facing the camera? A car light? Studio light?

Then direct flash from the camera, right?