By dragging in China into here, it shows your anti-China attitude.
Regardless of what the Chinese police will do, that does not mean we are doing the right thing here and the Canada line police just ...
peter236 發表於 2009-10-22 12:19
I do not say in this instant, the police is right or that lady is wrong. I am not there to witness so I cannot judge. People can only judge by the evidence so far.
My statement might not be appropriate but I just state based on my observation from the news. Judging from the situation described from the news, the lady seemed committing crimes by giving the kid tickets.
Personally I never encountered neither Canadian police or China police so I cannot tell you definitely which one is worse.
I do not say in this instant, the police is right or that lady is wrong. I am not there to witness so I cannot judge. People can only judge by the evidence so far.
My statement might not be appro ...
myversa 發表於 2009-10-22 12:00
I think the point of discussion is on whether the lady was abused by overuse of force, and whether the amount of force used is appropriate. There's no point dicussing whether Miss Chan violated the law as she admits herself that she was stupid in doing what she did.
As you said, the discussion and judgements are dependant on the 'evidence' so far, which really is just 口同nose拗.... other than the one 3rd party witness as mentioned in the other thread, this TW lady who sides Miss Chan's version of the story....
Regardless, the the outcome is gonna be either of the 3 i think:
1. the lady is lying and the video is released indicating so
2. the transit police is lying and the video is released indicating so
3. the transit police is lying and the video is never released
... May a transparent investigation be taken place, the right entities be held accountable, and our legal enforcement/judicial system be improved towards the right direction ...
When force is used on a person, some bruises and scrapes are unavoidable, unfortunately the broken tooth seems to indicate too much violence was involved. I wish Translink would release the video so we can see for ourselves.
This is what I concerned: 遭交通特警兩名男女警員圍著喝罵至驚哭
The police should not 喝罵至驚哭 to a 12 years old kid... imagine he is your brother or sister or son....
吳孟達 發表於 2009-10-20 19:06
100 % agree and children should be protected to certain extend.
發表於 2009-10-22 12:00
| 
