580 .. higher power .. but only if you need the extra power.
Also, 580 offers much better adjustable angle, (can reach more position vs 430) this is a big plus.
Also, 580 can use as master and other function, such as faster recycle time, and much quiter. (580II)
Most important, MADE in JAPAN .... ( good that you already kick Peter out, otherwise, he will say MADE IN CHINA flash > MADE IN JAPAN flash )
Down side, more heaver, more expensive.
I use my 430 more then my 580.  |