返回列表 發帖

Alberta farmer sentenced to 90 days in jail for shooting ATV thief

http://www.vancouversun.com/news ... /5521409/story.html

Alberta farmer Brian Russell Knight sentenced to 90 days in jail for shooting ATV thief
By Alexandra Zabjek, Postmedia News October 7, 2011 9:06 PM

EDMONTON — A central Alberta farmer who shot an ATV thief who crept onto his property was sentenced Friday to 90 days in jail.

The case of Brian Russell Knight had become a cause celebre among property rights activists, sparked debate about vigilante justice, and even drew comments from former premier Ed Stelmach who said he understood why Knight's neighbours rallied behind him and set up a trust fund to aid his legal defence.

But a lawyer for the 41-year-old Tees-area farmer could not convince a Red Deer judge that Knight should receive no jail time for shooting Harold Groening on March 26, 2009.

Knight will be allowed to serve his sentence on weekends in Red Deer's remand centre. He is also under the supervision of a probation officer.
...
The Crown had argued for a 90-day sentence. The defence wanted a conditional discharge, which would have left Knight without a criminal record after a period of probation.

Knight pleaded guilty in January to causing bodily harm by criminal negligence.

Court has previously heard that Groening and two other men went onto Knight's farm that night, and silently pushed an ATV, with keys in the ignition, to a rural road. All three men were under the influence of drugs and alcohol.

As the men struggled to lift the four-wheeler into the back of their truck on the road, the noise awoke Knight and his wife. After lights turned on at the farm, two of the thieves drove away in the truck, while Groening took the ATV. Knight pursued Groening in a car.

The two vehicles collided when Groening tried to veer across the road. He and the ATV were thrown in the ditch, yet Groening got to his feet and began running through a field.

Knight stopped his vehicle, raised a 12-gauge shotgun and aimed it in the general direction of the ATV thief.

Court has previously heard the shotgun was loaded with a "light type of birdshot" that struck Groening, who fell to the ground. When he got up, Knight fired again, though Groening continued to flee.

Knight then recruited his brother and other local farmers to help find the man who had tried to steal his ATV. When Groening was found, he was brought back to Knight's property and the RCMP called.

Groening, 32, who was briefly hospitalized after the incident, pleaded guilty to theft under $5,000 on April 22, 2010, and was sentenced to 30 days in jail.

So the thief got away with a 30 day jail sentence, while the redneck farmer defending his own property is hit with a 90 day jail sentence.

Something is clearly not right. The judges involved in this really needs to have their heads re-examined.

-Lik

TOP

C hing ... it is Canada ...  not GREAT CHINA ar .. of course, something is not right la...

TOP

he should not shoot the guy
I miss you...

TOP

咁應該點做﹖

打911等番個零兩個鐘班差佬歎完donut聯群結隊黎你屋企門口吹水﹖之後結論係too能bad有機會搵得番部ATV就叫你去認﹖

HK都仲話法律面前,窮人含撚; 呢度幾乎可以改話"人人含撚",睇你邊日唔好彩遇著呢D 濕滯野既姐。

TOP

偷少少野駛唔駛開槍射人呀... o係香港一定上頭條!
祝大家永遠快樂! ^^

TOP

Interestingly, there was a recent court ruling in Ontario where the judge ruled that homeowners are not required to flee intruders, and may in fact take violent steps to protect their home:

http://www.vancouversun.com/news ... /5419295/story.html

-Lik

TOP

偷少少野駛唔駛開槍射人呀... o係香港一定上頭條!
mcjohnjohn 發表於 2011/10/11 19:30


anyone who steals over $200 should be executed immediately
that's my ideal country

TOP

anyone who steals over $200 should be executed immediately
that's my ideal country
快樂牛郎 發表於 2011-10-12 11:56

咁你只好命中注定生活o係一個唔滿意既世界了.

TOP

之前多倫多超市東主果單我都覺得好有問題,保衛自己身家性命財產反而大罪過偷野咁....

我屋企車房以前俾人break in 過,好彩我返屋企途中撞破,自己追賊(條友推住部手推車走),終於有途人見到幫手條友拗底放棄我D野走左,我見到條友推住車仔走果陣已經打911,講到明我睇住條友走,o係咩位置,差佬都係兩個鐘意後先到

大城市入面已經係咁耐先有差佬到,ALBERTA D 農村地方十九幾個block先一間屋果D你唔自己顧自己,死L左都冇人知.....
FS: 15" snow tires with 4x100 rims package

TOP

返回列表